7.9.2021

Freedom of Contract in Demanding Construction Projects Should Not Be Limited in Legislative Reform

The past year and a half has forced construction companies to adapt in new ways. After an uncertain start, the resource and material shortage and the increase in prices have levelled out the growth of the construction industry. There has been no shortage of unexpected variables.

There is also an active public debate surrounding the quality of building construction and climate goals. The pending reform of the Land Use and Building Act intends to enact new circular economy and sustainability goals and attempts to address the quality issues, for example, through mandatory liability periods for various project parties. According to current information, the reform draft has mainly looked to traditional housing and infrastructure construction as well as the Finnish General Conditions for Building Contracts YSE 1998.

However, many extensive and demanding construction projects, such as power plant projects, are carried out using non-traditional models. The FIDIC contract forms are one example of a model that is in widespread use internationally, and the alliance model has also increased in popularity. Will lawmakers take these non-traditional models sufficiently into account when renewing the legislation?

Mandatory liability periods would be an additional legislative hurdle that should not be put in the way of extensive infrastructure and plant projects. The parties to these kinds of projects are often large international operators from a variety of countries. Taking the reform’s planned liabilities into account and incorporating them into the other levels of the contract chain could prove difficult if not impossible. At the end of the day, the cost of this risk will be paid by the owner, and there is no guarantee that the quality of building construction will improve. The same is true in investor-driven housing construction projects. Instead of enacting mandatory liability periods, lawmakers should trust agreements between professionals, which give demanding projects the freedom of action they need.

Latest references

Castrén & Snellman is acting as the legal advisor to the City of Pori in its sale of a 49% stake in Pori Energia to Polhem Infra. Pori Energia, a multi-utility company, operates in various sectors including district heating, electricity distribution, and electricity generation through CHP and renewable sources. The company also provides wind power services and industrial energy solutions in the Satakunta region. This strategic partnership between the City of Pori and Polhem Infra aims to enhance Pori Energia’s financial stability and investment capabilities, enabling the company to further its efforts in the energy transition and continue delivering high-quality energy services to its customers. Polhem Infra, owned by Swedish state pension funds, focuses on investments in critical infrastructure, including renewable electricity generation, energy storage, energy distribution, digital infrastructure, and transport infrastructure. The transaction values Pori Energia at EUR 905 million. 
Case published 31.1.2025
We successfully represented a Finnish manufacturing company in arbitration proceedings under the SCC rules against a global construction company. The dispute was governed by Finnish law and the seat of arbitration was Stockholm, Sweden. The dispute mainly concerned the termination of an erection contract and the right to compensation for delays of the project and for cost increases due to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The main questions in dispute were the lawfulness of the termination of the erection contract as well as the consequences of the termination such as the right to costs to complete the project after termination, the right to liquidated damages for delay of the project and adjustment of contract price due to cost increases. The total value of the dispute exceeded EUR 15 million.
Case published 8.1.2025
We are advising Oomi Oy in a business transaction whereby KSS Energia Oy’s consumer and business customers in the retail sale of electricity will be transferred to Oomi. The transfer is scheduled to take place in March 2025. The arrangement requires approval from the Finnish Competition and Consumer Authority. Oomi Oy is one of the largest energy service companies and electricity sellers in Finland. The arrangement is a result of the recent development of the electricity market and Oomi’s strategy, which aims to offer customers a seamless and improved digital customer experience.
Case published 20.12.2024
We are acting as the lead counsel to Fortum in a cross-border transaction in which Fortum is selling its recycling and waste business. The business is sold to thematic impact investing firm Summa Equity through its portfolio company NG Group. The debt-free purchase price is approximately EUR 800 million. The transaction is subject to authority approval and customary closing conditions. Fortum’s recycling and waste business to be sold comprises municipal and industrial waste management and end-to-end plastics, metals, ash, slag and hazardous waste treatment and recycling services. These businesses are located in Finland, Sweden, Denmark and Norway and currently employ approximately 900 employees.
Case published 18.7.2024