The Finnish Competition and Consumer Authority (FCCA) gave a decision, on 11 October 2016, concerning the customer bonus scheme of S Group, a major grocery retailer in Finland. The FCCA determined that the scheme did not restrict competition, and concluded its investigation.
12.10.2016
The FCCA Clarifies the Assessment Criteria of Customer Bonus Schemes
Related services
The FCCA decision clarifies which factors are relevant when assessing the effects of customer bonus schemes of dominant companies on effective competition.
Customer Bonus Schemes are an Accepted and Common Means of Competition
The matter concerns the S Bonus scheme where bonuses are paid to a customer based on his purchases from a dominant company or its scheme partners. According to the FCCA’s decision, this kind of customer bonus scheme is to be assessed as a so-called conditional discount. Conditional discounts are a common form of price competition, which companies can employ to promote the demand for their products and to benefit their consumers. The FCCA decision states that conditional discounts granted by a dominant company can also have beneficial effects from the consumers’ perspective. A discount mechanism applied by a dominant company may, however, have a loyalty-enhancing effect which can, in some circumstances, lead to anticompetitive foreclosure effects in the market.
Assessment of the Anticompetitive Foreclosure Effects
The assessment of the impacts of a customer bonus scheme is based on an overall assessment. The application of a scheme may amount to abuse of a dominant position if it prevents the expansion or entry of competitors that are as efficient as the dominant company or hinders the possibility of such competitors to fulfil a part of the purchase needs of individual customers.
According to the FCCA, this so-called as-efficient competitor test is, however, only one of the tools that can be used in assessing the effects of the discounts. Besides the costs, the FCCA also takes into account the following factors in its overall assessment:
Latest news
Latest references
Piippo – Sale of bale netwrap and baler twine machines and certain trademarks
We are acting as legal advisor to Piippo Plc in the sale of their bale netwrap and baler twine machines, related assets, and trademarks used in Piippo’s business to Portuguese Cotesi S.A. The sale of assets will be carried out in two phases and the final completion of the transaction is expected to occur during the first quarter of 2026. Piippo Oyj’s core business is baling nets and twine and it is one of the leading suppliers in the industry globally. The company’s global distribution network covers more than 40 countries. The company’s shares are listed on the First North Growth Market Finland operated by Nasdaq Helsinki Oy. Founded in 1967, Cotesi is one of the world’s leading producers of synthetic and natural twines, nets and ropes, with operations in Europe, North America and South America and its main production plant in Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal.
Case published 17.4.2025
KKR – Acquisition of Karo Healthcare
We acted as Finnish legal adviser to KKR in connection with its acquisition of the entire share capital of Karo Healthcare from EQT. The transaction follows Karo’s significant strategic transformation from a Nordic specialty pharma business into a leading pan-European consumer healthcare platform, with an attractive product portfolio spanning core categories such as Skin Health, Foot Health, and Intimate Health, as well as Digestive Health and Vitamins, Minerals & Supplements. KKR & Co. Inc. (NYSE: KKR), is a leading global investment firm that offers alternative asset management as well as capital markets and insurance solutions. KKR sponsors investment funds that invest in private equity, credit and real assets and has strategic partners that manage hedge funds. Completion of the transaction is subject to customary conditions and regulatory approvals. The transaction is expected to close in the coming months.
Case published 17.4.2025
Savings Banks Group – Sale of Sb Life Insurance
We advised the Savings Banks Group on an arrangement whereby the shares in Sp-Henkivakuutus Oy were sold to Henki-Fennia and at the same time the parties agreed on a long-term distribution cooperation for insurance savings and loan protection products. The closing of the transaction remains subject to regulatory approvals. Sb Life Insurance is a domestic life insurance company, established in 2007, offering insurance savings and risk insurance products to private customers and companies. The Savings Banks and Oma Säästöpankki Oyj act as agents for Sp-Life Insurance. Henki-Fennia is a subsidiary of Keskinäinen Vakuutusyhtiö Fennia, specialising in voluntary life, pension and savings insurance.
Case published 11.4.2025
Readpeak – Capital Investment
We advised Readpeak in an arrangement where Finnish growth fund Voland Partners made an investment in Readpeak. Readpeak is a service platform specialising in native advertising for purchasing, designing, and targeting the distribution of advertising space. Readpeak has quickly risen to a leading position with its platform solution, which enables an easy way to target and schedule communications as part of the news feed on media sites. Readpeak is a company founded in Helsinki in 2014, which has since expanded to nine European market areas and collaborates with over a thousand publishers. Readpeak redefines content-driven advertising using advanced machine learning models, creating added value for both quality media and journalism. Voland Partners is a minority investor specialising in the development of technology companies, with a mission to work together with entrepreneurs to build successful companies responsibly, creating success stories that benefit the entire society. Readpeak is Voland Partners’ sixth investment target, into which the fund company is investing from its first growth fund of 57 million euros.
Case published 10.4.2025