Working time records are generally thought of as a technical issue that has to be taken care of despite the fact that flexible arrangements and work results have become more important in modern working life than punching a time clock. However, the EU may be shaking up this status quo soon.
9.9.2021
Is the Clock Ticking on Working Time Regulation as We Know It? EU Working on Reform of Working Hour Regulation
Related services
The EU’s Working Time Directive requires that working hours must be measured using a system that is objective, reliable and accessible to all relevant parties. Be honest, do you already know what that kind of system actually looks like?
I can reveal to you that not many people yet know exactly what these criteria mean in practice. Nevertheless, based on preliminary ruling C-55/99 of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), the working hours records of all employers should fulfil the above criteria. This preliminary ruling concerned a situation in which an employer had only recorded overtime hours, as it was the common practice in Spain. The CJEU ruled that this does not meet the criteria of the Working Time Directive and that all working hours must be recorded.
In January 2021, the European Parliament also approved a draft for what is called the Right to Disconnect Directive, which would incorporate these criteria into EU legislation. It is time to take look at these criteria and think about how your company’s working hours records will work in the future.
The EU’s Working Time Directive has not changed much since its inception in the 1990s, despite the fact that the amount of related case law has ballooned and working life has taken leaps and bounds towards more flexible working time arrangements in the intervening years. Compiling and updating case law into EU legislation is a typical practice in EU law, and it seems that this may finally be around the corner for the regulation of working time.
In the following, I cover the main features of a working time record that is compliant with the Working Time Directive and provide a few tips on how companies can prepare for possible changes to EU working time legislation.
Objectivity and Reliability of Working Time Records
According to legal scholars, the objectivity and reliability criteria are clearly intertwined. The objectivity requirement encompasses the recording of actual working hours as well as an objective process for collecting this information. The reliability requirement more strongly highlights avoiding and preventing working hour entries from being purposefully or accidentally manipulated in such a way that they become false.
Employers should keep the following things in mind:
Access Criteria at Workplaces
According to the CJEU, access to working time records is essential, particularly with respect to their function as evidence. There are many interpretations of this requirement as well, but employers should keep in mind at least the following:
You Don’t Have to Give Up All Your Tried-and-True Practices
To be clear, it is worth noting that it will very likely remain possible to instruct employees to make working time entries, though the employer’s obligation to maintain working time records cannot be delegated. Workplaces also do not need to give up, for example, trust-based working hour models and flexible working time arrangements as long as they comply with current legislation.
It is also un likely that changes will be made to national legislation concerning working time records before a consensus on potential amendments is reached on the EU level. To this end, European labour market organisations have begun bilateral negotiations that are set to continue until 2024.
Could Proactive Workplaces Find a Working Time Record System Suited to Hybrid Work?
On the other hand, even if the EU’s working time legislation isn’t amended for years to come, working time arrangements may need to be updated at workplaces simply due to the increase in hybrid work. Given that the latest Working Time Directive was enacted in 2003, concepts like home office work, shared work stations and crowdworking cloud services were not part of the discussion at the time. Some legal scholars have said that we are currently shackled to an ‘antique’ and ‘conservative’ Working Time Directive, which presents obstacles to developing new practices.
If the goal of European labour market organisations is to increase flexibility in working life, achieving this goal will require a complete overhaul of the EU’s Working Time Directive. However, workplaces can take active and responsible measures now to influence, for example, what kinds of working time practices will be adopted to increase the flexibility of working life. The first step could be the kind of system for recording working time as described in the CJEU preliminary ruling C-55/19, which is a good fit also for hybrid work.
Latest insights
Article published 6.5.2024 – Employment
Outsourcing company functions – four key points for success
Article published 15.3.2024 – Employment
Five questions concerning industrial actions
Article published 29.11.2023 – Employment
Whistleblowing and data protection – frequently asked questions
Article published 22.2.2023 – Employment
Temporary agency work – 5 things all employers should be aware of
Tomi Kemppainen, Kim Parviainen & Eija Warma-Lehtinen
Mikko Hanni & Outi Tähtinen
Eija Warma-Lehtinen & Ville Kukkonen
Suvi Kettunen
Latest references
Merger of Oomi and Lumme Energia
We are acting as the joint legal advisor to Oomi Oy and Lumme Energia Oy in a transaction whereby Lumme Energia will merge with Oomi. As from the completion of the merger, the combined entity will be the largest electricity retail and service company in the Finnish market. In 2024, Oomi reported a turnover of EUR 373.9 million and had approximately 110 employees. Lumme Energia’s turnover for the same year was approximately EUR 314.6 million and it had approximately 50 employees. The transaction is primarily driven by the recent developments in the electricity market and the strategic goal to develop competitive products and services. Another key objective is to further enhance the customer experience, which is a shared value between the two companies. As a result of the merger, Lumme Energia’s customers will transfer to Oomi, and Lumme Energia will become one of Oomi’s shareholders. The completion of the transaction is subject to an approval by the Finnish Competition and Consumer Authority.
Case published 29.8.2025
HANZA – Acquisition of Milectria
We acted as Finnish legal advisor to HANZA AB in connection with its acquisition of the contract manufacturing division of Milectria, a group of companies specialising in electrical systems for the defence industry. The transaction comprises 100% of the shares in Milectria Oy (Finland), Milectria OÜ (Estonia), and the real estate company Kiinteistö Oy Kanungin Karhu. The transaction is expected to close in September 2025, subject to customary closing conditions, including regulatory approvals. Founded in 2008, HANZA is a Swedish mechanical engineering and electronics contract manufacturing company listed on the Nasdaq Stockholm main list. The company operating in seven countries currently has annual sales of approximately SEK 6 billion and approximately 3,100 employees. Milectria is a Finnish contract manufacturer of electrical systems for the defence industry.
Case published 21.7.2025
Nevel – Acquisition of Labio’s business
We advised Nevel Oy in its acquisition of the business of Labio Oy. Lahti Aqua Oy and Salpakierto Oy sold their entire shareholdings in Labio to Nevel, expanding Nevel’s already significant biogas portfolio. The transaction will have no impact on Lahti Aqua’s water utility operations or Salpakierto’s municipal waste management responsibilities. Labio’s operations and customer relationships will continue as before. ‘This partnership is a natural next step for us as we continue investing in sustainable material efficiency and renewable energy solutions. By integrating Labio’s comprehensive offerings and expertise, we can provide customers with a strong platform for material circularity. We are also strengthening our market position as one of Finland’s leading material efficiency solution providers,’ says Ville Koikkalainen, Director of Industrial and Biogas Business at Nevel. Nevel is an energy infrastructure company offering advanced, climate-positive solutions for industry and real estate. It operates more than 130 energy production plants and manages over 40 district heating networks. Nevel’s annual turnover is EUR 150 million, and it employs 190 experts in Finland, Sweden and Estonia.
Case published 16.7.2025
Pihlajalinna – Sale of special housing services
We advised Pihlajalinna Plc on an arrangement whereby Pihlajalinna Terveys Oy and Ikipihlaja Setälänpiha Oy sold their special housing services business to Esperi Care Oy. The transaction involved three Pihlajalinna Uniikki units in Hämeenlinna, Lohja and Riihimäki as well as Ikipihlaja Oiva in Raisio. As a result of the arrangement, more than 100 employees transferred to Esperi. Pihlajalinna is one of Finland’s leading private providers of social and healthcare services, offering a wide range of services to both private and public sector clients. Pihlajalinna has more than 160 locations across Finland.
Case published 2.6.2025