21.9.2015

Disruptive Internet Services Face to Face With Finnish Law

New innovative internet services, like Uber and Airbnb, have triumphed in many countries and are now also finding their way into Finland. Although these services and the new business opportunities they bring have been given a warm welcome by many, the Finnish authorities and the more traditional industry players have been more reserved.

On the other hand, the renowned Bengt Holmström, Professor of Economics at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), has said that ‘the Internet, robots and the digitalisation of business are like laws of nature. Their development cannot be prevented. The more we deny new business models, the more we will fall behind’ [1]. Instead of being given the opportunity to flourish, these new services are sometimes seen as troublemakers, and seem to have hit a tightly knit web of laws and regulations hindering them in this country.

In this post we discuss two of these ‘new kids on the block’ and the legal hurdles they have found themselves facing in Finland.

Uber

Uber provides a service that connects customers in need of a ride with available drivers via a smartphone app. In Finland, this great innovation has faced strong opposition as the authorities have found it hard to fit Uber into the classic and heavily regulated taxi service model. 

As in some other countries, operating a taxi in Finland requires a license. Only a restricted number of taxi licenses are available, and room for newcomers is very limited. The problem with Uber appears to be that the Finnish authorities have a hard time establishing whether the service Uber provides is to be classified as operating a taxi and, therefore, requiring a license.

According to Uber itself, it is not a taxi service, but only provides a platform for ride sharing. Regardless of the ambiguity regarding the nature of Uber’s service, the Finnish Taxi Association has stated that drivers with a valid license have been urged to report Uber drivers to the authorities.

Lately even the Finnish police asked the public to report Uber drivers to the police. This is due to an ongoing investigation in which the authorities are trying to establish whether or not Uber is in breach of Finnish taxi legislation and driver safety requirements. Instead of actively rethinking the passenger transport business and considering the benefits of more flexible services, the authorities seem to be more willing to deny Uber’s business entirely.

Airbnb

Uber is not alone in its struggle with the tight web of Finnish laws and regulations. Airbnb, which provides an online platform for people to rent out properties to others in need of short-term accommodation, has also come under the all-seeing eye of the Finnish authorities, who see Airbnb’s operating model as some shade of grey in legal terms.

At the moment, the authorities are trying to decide whether it is a temporary rental to help offset vacation costs, whether it subletting or whether it is an accommodation business – all three possible interpretations are firmly regulated.

The Finnish Hospitality Association, MaRa, has demanded that the same tax liabilities and the numerous regulations that apply to other service providers in the accommodation business, such as hotels, should also apply to Airbnb. According to MaRa’s argument, Airbnb has an unfair competitive advantage otherwise.

In addition, residential buildings – generally organised in Finland as a special type of limited liability company that residents own shares in – are considering whether they could and should prohibit short-term rentals in their articles of association because of the possible disturbances travellers might cause.

These Services are Here to Stay

Digitalisation is not a new topic in Finland. Even the new government’s platform underlines the importance of digitalisation. However, new and innovative services are often not welcomed with open arms in practice.

Finns want these new services and the benefits they bring in terms of new business opportunities, cheaper consumer prices and more options to choose from. Keeping in mind the relative small size of the Finnish market, none of these benefits are self-evident and new business models enabling them should be encouraged rather than weeded out.

Indeed, instead of building legal barriers to their development, we should be breaking down old barriers and looking ahead. Fortunately Bengt Holmström sees that there is hope in Finland. As encouraging examples Holmström mentions software companies, the video game industry, Slush and the whole Finnish startup scene.

The best way to face the challenges of digitalisation is to actively take part in it and find new ways to support it instead of fighting against it.

[1] http://www.hs.fi/talous/a1439870365925  

Discussion in the Finnish Media

Uber:

Helsingin Sanomat: Poliisi kehottaa tekemään Uber-kuskeista ilmoituksen – “Akuutissa tilanteessa soitto hätäkeskukseen”

Iltalehti: Näinkö kohuyhtiö Uber ratkaisee kiistansa myös Suomessa? Haluaa eroon kuskeista

Nyt.fi: Call 911 if you see an Uber, Finnish police says

Edilex: Uber-kyytien välitys laillista, mutta ajaminen vaatii taksiluvan

Yle: Taxi Association demands Uber intervention

Yle: Taxi industry deregulation only a matter of time, says expert – even in Finland

Mtv3: Ministeriö: Uber-taksipalvelu ei voisi tulla Suomeen ainakaan heti

Airbnb:

Helsingin Sanomat: Vuokralaiset välittivät luvatta helsinkiläismiehen asuntoa kuukausia Airbnb-turisteille

Yle: Finland learning to live with Airbnb

Yle: Tuesday’s papers: Centre, Finns parties reach consensus, Airbnb headaches, online cellphone deal turns into knifepoint robbery

Iltasanomat: Airbnb:n toiminta Suomessa raivostuttaa: ”Täysin kestämätöntä”

MaRa: MaRa tekee yksityisiä majoituspalveluja koskevan lainsäädäntöaloitteen

Helsingin Sanomat: Alivuokrausta ei voi kieltää

Latest references

We are acting as the lead counsel to Fortum in a cross-border transaction in which Fortum is selling its recycling and waste business. The business is sold to thematic impact investing firm Summa Equity through its portfolio company NG Group. The debt-free purchase price is approximately EUR 800 million. The transaction is subject to authority approval and customary closing conditions. Fortum’s recycling and waste business to be sold comprises municipal and industrial waste management and end-to-end plastics, metals, ash, slag and hazardous waste treatment and recycling services. These businesses are located in Finland, Sweden, Denmark and Norway and currently employ approximately 900 employees.
Case published 18.7.2024
We advised Andritz Oy, a part of ANDRITZ group, with their acquisition of all the shares in Procemex Oy. The acquisition further strengthens ANDRITZ’s automation and digitalisation portfolio. Procemex is a global leader in integrated web monitoring and web inspection solutions for the pulp and paper industry. It has a team of more than 100 vision systems experts and has subsidiaries in Germany, Japan and the US. ANDRITZ offers a broad portfolio of innovative plants, equipment, systems, services and digital solutions for a wide range of industries and end markets. ANDRITZ is a global market leader in all four of its business areas – Pulp & Paper, Metals, Hydropower and Environment & Energy. The publicly listed group has around 30,000 employees and over 280 locations in more than 80 countries.
Case published 18.7.2024
We successfully acted as the lead external counsel for Citycon Plc in an arrangement whereby Citycon outsourced its Nordic Accounting and Lease Administration operations and related workforce in Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark and Estonia to Staria Plc. The outsourcing is expected to take place as of 1 August 2024. With this outsourcing arrangement, Citycon aims to align the size and capabilities of the company’s finance organisation with its future development, ensuring it can adapt to meet the company’s needs at any given time. During the assignment, we assisted Citycon in drafting the necessary contract documentation and planning the contract negotiations and timetable. We led the outsourcing agreement negotiations and advised Citycon on employee transfer and data privacy related matters. We also coordinated legal advice for other in-scope countries. Citycon is the leading owner and developer of urban hubs in the Nordics and Baltics. Citycon’s 33 mixed-use, necessity-based centres are located in the major cities in Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark and Estonia. Citycon transforms unique locations into sustainable communities and cities full of life, serving 140 million people each year and delivering long-term share value. Citycon brings value to communities by developing urban hubs for living, working, socialising and shopping. Citycon has extensive experience as an urban developer and uses its expertise in creating mixed-use centres that include retail, offices, hotels, housing, food & beverage as well as healthcare, culture and leisure services.
Case published 13.5.2024
We acted as Zendesk, Inc.’s Finnish legal counsel in its acquisition of Ultimate Enterprises Oy, an industry leading provider of service automation using AI technology. The cross-border acquisition was completed in cooperation with the transaction’s lead counsel Allen & Overy. Zendesk is a leading global technology company that provides software-as-a-service and customer experience (CX) products based in the US. The acquisition of Ultimate expands Zendesk’s AI-powered CX offerings.
Case published 26.3.2024