26.9.2018

Transfer Tax Advice – Assistance in a transfer tax matter concerning the repayment of guarantee capital

We assisted our client in a transfer tax matter concerning the repayment of guarantee capital.

The Finnish Tax Administration issued a preliminary ruling according to which the transferee was obligated to pay transfer tax on the repayment of guarantee capital when the guarantee capital was repaid due to liquidation. The Finnish Tax Administration ruled that the repayment of guarantee capital due to liquidation was, in fact, a payment made for the transfer of guarantee shares, which meant that transfer tax was payable on the repayment of the guarantee capital.

In a decision issued on 12 September 2018, the Helsinki Administrative Court overturned the Finnish Tax Administration’s ruling. It was undisputed in the case that the mutual insurance company’s guarantee share was a security, the transfer of which is subject to transfer tax under section 15 of the Transfer Tax Act. The issue being decided was whether the title to the guarantee shares is transferred to the mutual insurance company when the guarantee capital is repaid when the insurance company is liquidated, and thus, whether the repayment of the guarantee capital gives rise to liability for transfer tax.

The Administrative Court stated that the matter concerned a repayment of guarantee capital in relation to the liquidation of a company as referred to in chapter 23, section 22(2) of the Insurance Companies Act. The question was not of a performance to be deemed an acquisition or redemption of guarantee shares, rather it was a statutory distribution of funds of a liquidating company to the owner of the guarantee share. As no transfer of title took place, the repayment of guarantee capital in connection with the liquidation of the company was not a transfer that the company was liable to pay transfer tax on in accordance with the Transfer Tax Act.

The Supreme Administrative Court did not grant leave to appeal to the Tax Recipients’ Legal Services Unit, so the Administrative Court’s decision is final.

Helsinki Administrative Court 12 September 2018, record No 18/0784/6, docket No 01016/18/8510.

Latest references

Castrén & Snellman is acting as the legal advisor to the City of Pori in its sale of a 49% stake in Pori Energia to Polhem Infra. Pori Energia, a multi-utility company, operates in various sectors including district heating, electricity distribution, and electricity generation through CHP and renewable sources. The company also provides wind power services and industrial energy solutions in the Satakunta region. This strategic partnership between the City of Pori and Polhem Infra aims to enhance Pori Energia’s financial stability and investment capabilities, enabling the company to further its efforts in the energy transition and continue delivering high-quality energy services to its customers. Polhem Infra, owned by Swedish state pension funds, focuses on investments in critical infrastructure, including renewable electricity generation, energy storage, energy distribution, digital infrastructure, and transport infrastructure. The transaction values Pori Energia at EUR 905 million. 
Case published 31.1.2025
We advised a fund managed by Swiss Life Asset Managers Nordic in its acquisition of a logistics property in Hyvinkää from a fund managed by Savills Investment Management. In addition to advising on the transactional aspects, we also advised on the financing of the acquisition as well as in designing an appropriate international acquisition structure and addressing relevant tax implications. The property serves as the central warehouse in Finland for Ahlsell, a leading Nordic technical wholesaler, which has been leasing the property since its construction. The state-of-the-art logistics centre was originally built in 2002 and has undergone several improvement projects over the years. The latest extension, completed in 2024, added around 11,000 square meters of new storage area to the property, bringing the total lettable area to 47,000 square meters. The property has been developed with a strong emphasis on energy efficiency with on-site solar power and renewable district heating. The sustainability features of the property were also further optimised and the asset just received BREEAM Excellent certifications in both BREEAM New Construction and BREEAM In-Use.
Case published 20.1.2025
We advised CapMan Buyout in the exit of Renoa Group. Renoa Group management together with Korpi Capital and other investors have acquired the group. Renoa Group is a Finnish established expert in the building technology sector specializing in detached houses in Finland and Sweden. Renoa is a major provider of turnkey domestic water & heating, sewer system and electricity network renovations, with significant operations also in Sweden. The Group reported sales of €35 million and employed c. 300 personnel across its 10 offices in Finland and 6 in Sweden. Korpi Capital is a Finnish investment company with holdings in 29 companies. 
Case published 14.1.2025
We are acting as a counsel to Fortum in a transaction in which Fortum is strengthening its renewable power project pipeline through the acquisition of a project development portfolio from Enersense. The debt-and-cash free purchase price is approximately EUR 9 million, with the potential for project-specific earn-outs subject to projects successfully reaching a final investment decision in the future. The transaction is subject to customary closing conditions and is expected to be completed during the first quarter of 2025. Fortum is a leading Nordic energy company with the purpose to power a world where people, businesses and nature thrive together. Fortum’s core operations comprise of efficient, CO2-free power generation as well as reliable supply of electricity and district heat to private and business customers. The company is listed on Nasdaq Helsinki. One of Fortum’s strategic targets is to develop at least 800 MW of ready-to-build onshore wind and solar projects by the end of 2026.
Case published 19.12.2024