Responsible Influencer Marketing is Your Calling Card
Marketing is constantly changing shape and expanding to new platforms. For example, traditional print marketing is increasingly being replaced by commercial cooperation with carefully chosen social media influencers. Influencer marketing is usually much better at reaching the desired target group. However, it is important to remember that newer forms of marketing are still subject to the Finnish Consumer Protection Act’s provisions concerning good marketing practices and improper marketing.
‘We’re Just Sending Review Products–That’s Not Marketing, Is It?’
Sending products to an Instragram influencer, YouTuber or blogger in the hopes that they will mention the product on their channel counts as marketing, even if no commercial cooperation has actually been agreed—the requirements that marketing be identifiable still apply.
From the perspective of the Consumer Protection Act, all activities that seek to influence consumers commercially are essentially marketing. Influence can be direct or indirect, but it can never be hidden.
Consumers Have the Right to Know When Someone Is Attempting to Influence them Commercially
The Consumer Protection Act’s requirement for the identification of marketing has two dimensions. First, marketing must clearly show its commercial purpose and on whose behalf it is. The purpose of the identification requirement is that consumers can see when and on whose behalf someone is attempting to influence them commercially. This requirement applies to all marketing regardless of method.
The identification of marketing has given rise to a great deal of debate both in Finland and abroad. The Council of Ethics in Advertising of the Finland Chamber of Commerce has issued numerous statements on the identification of marketing on social media. Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) in Great Britain has gone so far as to publish a ‘naming and shaming’ list of influencers who do not mark commercial cooperation clearly enough, in other words, who engage in hidden advertising.
Clear and Visible at First Glance
One statement issued last year concerned the identification of an advertisement on the Instagram Story feature. The Story feature allows influencers to post pictures, text and short videos to Instagram that are visible for 24 hours. The Story post in question was marked as commercial cooperation by putting text in the upper corner of the post. However, this text was partially covered by the influencer’s username and profile picture. The white font of the text also partially blended in with the background, which hindered identification.
The conclusion was that the advertisement published using the Story feature was not clearly identifiable as advertising to the average consumer. There are two points worth highlighting from the reasoning:
- If it is possible to confuse an advertisement for editorial material for any reason, it must be marked as an advertisement so that consumers can identify the attempt at influencing them commercially.
- The overall assessment was based not only on the channel, but also by the location of the advertising mark, the choice of words, and the type, size and colour of the font.
The identification of advertising is always subject to an overall assessment. For example, using the Instagram Story feature emphasises the requirement for clarity, because the feature uses quickly changing pictures and videos. The fact that a post is an advertisement and the name of the advertiser must be clearly marked on advertisements published using the feature in such a way that they can be seen at a glance.
Identification Requirement Emphasised on Social Media
The expansion of the field of advertising can also be seen in a decision concerning a YouTube video concerning plastic surgery. According to the advertiser, the video was not made for the purposes of advertising, rather the YouTuber in question approached the advertiser to make the video. The existence of cooperation had been stated in the publication information, which could be read by clicking on ‘Show more’. This was found to be hidden advertising.
The decision also separately stated that it did not matter who approached who to make the video. The Council of Ethics in Advertising noted that the identification of advertising and the mentioning of the advertiser is emphasised in social media posts that contain a great deal of editorial material. A large number of the YouTuber’s viewers were minors, which also made the advertising inappropriate. The advertiser was issued a warning.
Companies Bear Liability and Brand Risk
The above decisions show that advertisers have to know their environment. It is essential to know what platforms are being used for advertising and what the influencer’s target audience is like. For example, in the plastic surgery case, a large number of the viewers were minors, which meant that the marketing should have taken particular care not only with respect to identification, but also to complying with good practices and being suitable for minors.
It is vital for companies to remember that they ultimately bear the legal liability and brand risk for marketing through influencers. A company can free itself from liability if it can prove that it gave the influencer sufficient instructions on how to carry out the marketing. This means that it is particularly important to draft an agreement on influencer cooperation that makes the obligations concerning the identification of advertising sufficiently clear.
Responsible marketing can also be a calling card. Consumers are increasingly aware and see hidden marketing as unprofessional. Consumers remember brands that engage in good and transparent marketing as responsible and positive actors.
Influencer Marketing Checklist
- If the purpose of cooperation is to have a commercial influence, it is always marketing subject to the Finnish Consumer Protection Act and must be identified as such.
- Always agree in writing on how influencer marketing is to be carried out in practice.
- The party on whose behalf the marketing takes place is ultimately responsible for the contents of the marketing.
- Give clear instructions to influencers on carrying out the marketing. If you want to give the influencer free hands, it is still important to go over the minimum requirements: contents that are not suited to the brand do not serve their purpose.
- Remember the two dimensions of the identification requirement for marketing:
- Make sure that the commercial nature of marketing is clearly visible at first glance.
- Make sure that any marketing shows on whose behalf it is being carried out.